Custodians, Chapter 8: The Custodian

Plant It Anyway

, 2 min read

Young coconut palm seedlings growing from the ground
Photo by Alexey Demidov on Pexels

There is a hadith that I find harder to absorb than almost anything else in the tradition, because it refuses to make sense on the terms I usually think in.

The Prophet ﷺ said that if the Hour is about to be established and one of you has a palm shoot in his hand, and he is able to plant it before the Hour arrives, let him plant it.

Read that again slowly. The world is ending. Not declining, not in trouble, ending, imminently. The shoot will not grow. There is no time for it to grow. There will be no one to eat the dates and nowhere for the tree to stand.

Plant it anyway.

Every instinct I have been trained in says this is irrational. I have spent my working life around systems that are judged on outcomes. Did it ship. Did it hold. Did the number move. An action that cannot possibly produce a result is, in that language, waste.

And the hadith says: plant it.


What it is doing, I think, is detaching the worth of an action from the result of it, which sounds like a minor philosophical adjustment and is in fact a full replacement of the operating logic.

Because if you are an owner, outcomes are the whole point. You act in order to acquire, and an action that acquires nothing is a cost with no return. Of course you would not plant.

If you are holding something in trust, the logic runs differently. You were given a shoot. Planting shoots is what the trust consists of. What happens after it is in the ground was never in your remit, was never promised to you, and is not the thing you will be asked about. You will be asked whether you planted.

The results belong to the Owner. The planting belongs to you.


So here is the test, and it is one question, and it does not require a theological education.

Am I holding this to circulate, or am I holding this to keep?

That is it. Ask it about a sum of money, and notice that the honest answer arrives before the justification does.

If the answer is to keep, the grip has started. That is not a moral failure, it is a diagnostic reading, and you can take it the way you would take a temperature.

Which is why the palm shoot is the right image to end on. It is not a heroic act. A man puts a plant in the ground on the last afternoon of the world, knowing exactly what it will amount to, because putting plants in the ground is what he was given hands for.

Hold it lightly. Spend it well. Give it back.